The Museum of Australian Democracy acknowledges the traditional owners and custodians of country throughout Australia. We recognise their continuing connection to land, waters and community. We pay our respects to the people, the cultures and the elders past, present and emerging.

The museum respectfully acknowledges the role that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples continue to play in shaping Australia’s democracy.

xClose
Museum of Australian Democracy at Old Parliament House
  • About
  • Blog
  • Prime Ministers
  • Websites
  • Venue hire
  • Visiting
  • What's On
  • Collection
  • Learning
  • Democracy
Museum of Australian Democracy at Old Parliament House
  • Visiting
    • Planning your visit
    • Families at MoAD
    • Access
    • Group bookings
    • Cafe
    • MoAD Shop
    • UNSW Canberra Howard Library
  • What’s On
    • Exhibitions
    • Events
  • Collection
    • The Building
    • Objects and rooms
    • Oral Histories
  • Learning
    • Teachers
    • Students
    • Parents
  • Democracy
    • Democracy 2025
    • Defining democracy
    • Australian democracy: an overview
    • The democratic audit of Australia
    • One thing I like about democracy
    • Links
    • Quotes
    • Notes
    • About
    • Blog
    • Prime Ministers
    • Websites
    • Venue hire
    From the blog

    How are party leaders chosen?

    6 minute read

    Wed 23 Jun 2021 by

    Another leadership spill? Here we go again. The National Party replaced its leader Michael McCormack with former leader Barnaby Joyce, an unexpected change in Deputy Prime Minister.

    While plenty will joke about it, the way parties choose their leaders is a critical part of the parliamentary system, and while each party has slightly different rules, they all follow some basic principles. 

    We know early Australian leaders were elected by their party rooms, but we often don’t know much at all about how that process worked. Sometimes when a ballot was held, we don’t even know what the numbers were. In today’s era you can find out a lot more and follow each change in real time on social media.

    Here’s how each of the main Australian parties in the federal parliament chooses its leader.

    Labor

    Up until recently, Labor followed the simple model most parties did - the party room (in Labor’s case called the Caucus) would meet, and a simple ballot would be held. Certainly at least since the 1990s, the ballots were on paper, and counted by an official.

    In 2013 a change was announced and now the ALP’s federal leader, as well as those in some states, are chosen by a combination of the party’s rank-and-file members and Caucus. To be elected leader, a candidate needs to win enough votes in both. In 2013, Bill Shorten’s victory in Caucus was large enough that it offset Anthony Albanese’s victory in the member vote, and he was elected leader. In 2019 Albanese would have faced the same process, but he was ultimately unopposed and no vote took place.

    Since 2013, Labor’s Caucus has a rule that either 60% (in opposition) or 75% (in government) of Caucus has to agree before the leader can be removed, but this is only a Caucus rule and not in the party constitution. 

    The ballot papers from both of Paul Keating’s leadership challenges against Bob Hawke, the first ever against a sitting prime minister, are in the Museum of Australian Democracy’s collection after they were salvaged by the party’s returning officer, Jim McKiernan.

    Liberal

    The Liberal Party’s rules are mostly unchanged from its foundation; a majority vote by the party room, just as Labor’s once was. In the case of multiple candidates, a run-off system is used where the lowest-polling candidate is eliminated and a new vote held until there’s a winner. In 2018, Scott Morrison introduced a new rule that if a prime minister goes to a general election and wins it, a two-thirds majority is needed to remove him or her from the leadership. Both this and Labor’s changes were brought in to prevent what seemed to many people as an unusual and unnecessary ‘revolving door’ of leadership while in power.

    The Nationals

    The National Party follows the same system as the Liberals - a simple majority of members of the party room is enough to elect a leader, who in government is invariably Deputy Prime Minister, even if elected straight from the backbench. The party’s constitution gives the party room the power to dictate the rules of election so it could easily change it if it ever wanted to.

    The Greens

    The Australian Greens’ constitution doesn’t outline how the leader is chosen and leaves it to the party room. Currently, a simple majority in the party room is all that’s needed. There is an active movement within the Greens, including all the former party leaders, that wants to give rank-and-file members a say in the party’s leadership. 

    In most Westminster democracies, the “simple vote in the party room” model has been largely dispensed with. Most parties in the UK, New Zealand and Canada no longer use it and have some form of ballot taken by their grassroots members. Is Australia behind the times? Some argue that since the leader is first and foremost responsible to the party room, the party room should choose them. Others believe ordinary party members having a say democratises the process, makes the leader more accountable, and drives recruitment. 

    Should rank-and-file members, or even voters, be choosing party leaders? Or is it best left to politicians? 

    6 minute read

    Wed 23 Jun 2021 by

    Museum of Australian Democracy at Old Parliament House

    18 King George Terrace, Parkes, ACT 2600, Australia

    PO Box 3934
    Manuka ACT 2603

    9am to 5pm daily 
    Closed Christmas Day

    ABN: 30 620 774 963

    Telephone: 02 6270 8222

    Enquiries:
    info@moadoph.gov.au

    Please note: video surveillance is used 24 hours a day around and throughout the building and may be used for research purposes

    Visiting

    • Planning your visit
    • Families at MoAD
    • Access
    • Group bookings
    • Cafe
    • MoAD Shop
    • UNSW Canberra Howard Library

    What's On

    • Events
    • Exhibitions

    Collection

    • The building
    • Objects and rooms
    • Highlights
    • Oral histories

    Learning

    • Teachers
    • Students
    • Parents

    Democracy

    • Exploring democracy
    • Documenting a democracy
    • Australian democracy
    • Defining democracy
    • Democracy 2025

    About

    • OPH Board
    • Annual Reports
    • Budget
    • Corporate documents
    • Disability Inclusion Action Plan
    • Employment
    • Freedom of information
    • Public Interest Disclosure
    • Media
    • Newsletter
    • Support us
    • Partnerships
    • Our prime minister patrons
    • Donate to our collection
    • eCommerce terms and conditions
    • Online house rules

    Blog

    Prime Ministers

    Websites

    Further information

    View our recruitment opportunities.

    View our copyright policy.

    View our privacy statement.

    View our ticketing terms and conditions.

    Questions about the website:
    website@moadoph.gov.au

    The Museum of Australian Democracy at Old Parliament House is a Corporate Commonwealth Entity within the Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development, Communications and the Arts