The Museum of Australian Democracy acknowledges the traditional owners and custodians of country throughout Australia. We recognise their continuing connection to land, waters and community. We pay our respects to the people, the cultures and the elders past, present and emerging.

The museum respectfully acknowledges the role that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples continue to play in shaping Australia’s democracy.

xClose
Museum of Australian Democracy at Old Parliament House
  • About
  • Blog
  • Prime Ministers
  • Websites
  • Venue hire
  • Visiting
  • What's On
  • Collection
  • Learning
  • Democracy
Museum of Australian Democracy at Old Parliament House
  • Visiting
    • Planning your visit
    • Families at MoAD
    • Access
    • Group bookings
    • Cafe
    • MoAD Shop
    • UNSW Canberra Howard Library
  • What’s On
    • Exhibitions
    • Events
  • Collection
    • The Building
    • Objects and rooms
    • Oral Histories
  • Learning
    • Teachers
    • Students
    • Parents
  • Democracy
    • Democracy 2025
    • Defining democracy
    • Australian democracy: an overview
    • The democratic audit of Australia
    • One thing I like about democracy
    • Links
    • Quotes
    • Notes
    • About
    • Blog
    • Prime Ministers
    • Websites
    • Venue hire
    From the blog

    Would you vote for conscription? Five objects to help you decide

    7 minute read

    Fri 28 Oct 2016 by
    Campbell Rhodes
    • collection
    • democracy
    • research

    A century ago, Australians faced one of the most bitter and passionate debates in our history.

    The First World War was being fought across Europe, and Australia had sustained huge losses at Gallipoli and the western front. Prime Minister Billy Hughes was adamant conscripts needed to be sent to fight to make up the numbers. Britain and some of the other Dominions already had conscription to bolster their reinforcements, and Hughes was determined to follow suit. Faced with a party unwilling to support him and falling political capital, Hughes put this question to the voters in a non-binding plebiscite (referred to by some sources as a referendum):

    Are you in favour of the Government having, in this grave emergency, the same compulsory powers over citizens in regard to requiring their military service, for the term of this War, outside the Commonwealth, as it now has in regard to military service within the Commonwealth?

    How would you have voted? Here are five objects from the Museum’s collection which might help you make up your mind.

    1. Honouring our commitments

    'Vote Yes' referendum poster

    Andrew Fisher, the Labor leader, made his famous statement to fight the looming war to the ‘last man and the last shilling’ at an election speech in Colac on 31 July 1914. Fisher’s words were used on this poster for the ‘yes’ campaign. The case was very clear: in order to honour our commitment to the Empire, Australians had to have more manpower and needed conscription to bring reinforcements to the front.

    An image of the handbill with the poem 'The Blood Vote'

    2. The Blood Vote

    This poem is credited to W.R. Winspear, but recent claims have stated it was actually written by journalist E.J. Dempsey, who was unable to publish it under his name for political reasons. The art is by Claude Marquet, one of Australia’s most prolific cartoonists of the early 20th century. This handbill was widely distributed and printed in major newspapers.

    3. Vote No Mum

    This poster prominently features the Australian Labor Party, doubling as both a party advertisement and a call against conscription.

    'Vote No Mum' poster

    The ALP was one of the main contributors to the ‘no’ campaign. This was despite Prime Minister Billy Hughes being leader of the party. By the time of the plebiscite, Hughes’ stock had fallen so low within Labor he had already been expelled as a member, although he kept attending (and chairing) party meetings without challenge. Two weeks after the vote, on 14 November, Hughes’ leadership was rejected by caucus and he walked out. Hughes’ departure split Labor into two camps, one of which merged with the opposition to become the Nationalist Party before the 1917 election. The fallout from the split saw Labor confined to opposition for more than a decade.

    4. Keep Australia White

    Keep Australia White poster

    Not all of the ‘no’ case was based on the morality of asking people to fight against their will. One of the more powerful and resonant arguments was about the White Australia Policy. Opponents believed conscription would cause a labour shortage in Australia which would be filled by importing workers from overseas, such as Asia or the Pacific, and that this would mean an end to White Australia. The overt racism of such a position is shocking now but at the time this was considered a reasonable point.

    5. For the Flag

    An image of a 'vote yes' political badge

    The conscription debate polarised Australia like nothing before, and arguably nothing since. Tempers were inflamed and passions aroused on both sides as the day of the plebiscite grew near. Both the pro and anti-conscription campaigners wore their colours for all to see, and badges either for or against conscription were produced in their thousands. This badge for the ‘yes’ case invokes the familiar themes; a vote for conscription is a vote for Australia, Britain and the Empire.

    Both sides campaigned actively, but the result was a narrow victory for ‘no’, with 1,087,557 in favour and 1,160,033 against. Victoria, Western Australia and Tasmania voted Yes, in the case of WA by a 2-1 margin. In just over a year, the whole exercise was repeated with a second plebiscite campaign, which was just as, if not more, divisive and emotional than the first but which was, also, rejected.

    Even though both the 1916 and 1917 plebiscites were non-binding, the Hughes government made the decision to honour the will of Australian voters, and no further efforts were made to bring about conscription. Australia would eventually introduce conscription for limited overseas service during the Second World War, and the role of conscripts during the Vietnam War has been much-debated.

    So which way would you have voted? Let us know in the comments. 

    7 minute read

    Fri 28 Oct 2016 by
    Campbell Rhodes
    • collection
    • democracy
    • research
    Museum of Australian Democracy collection

    Museum of Australian Democracy collection

    Campbell has been the Curatorial Officer at the Museum since 2012 and has worked in the sector for almost a decade. He is passionate about telling stories through objects and activities, and equally passionate about the hopelessly large pile of books he hasn’t got around to reading yet.

    Museum of Australian Democracy at Old Parliament House

    18 King George Terrace, Parkes, ACT 2600, Australia

    PO Box 3934
    Manuka ACT 2603

    9am to 5pm daily 
    Closed Christmas Day

    ABN: 30 620 774 963

    Telephone: 02 6270 8222

    Enquiries:
    info@moadoph.gov.au

    Please note: video surveillance is used 24 hours a day around and throughout the building and may be used for research purposes

    Visiting

    • Planning your visit
    • Families at MoAD
    • Access
    • Group bookings
    • Cafe
    • MoAD Shop
    • UNSW Canberra Howard Library

    What's On

    • Events
    • Exhibitions

    Collection

    • The building
    • Objects and rooms
    • Highlights
    • Oral histories

    Learning

    • Teachers
    • Students
    • Parents

    Democracy

    • Exploring democracy
    • Documenting a democracy
    • Australian democracy
    • Defining democracy
    • Democracy 2025

    About

    • OPH Board
    • Annual Reports
    • Budget
    • Corporate documents
    • Disability Inclusion Action Plan
    • Employment
    • Freedom of information
    • Public Interest Disclosure
    • Media
    • Newsletter
    • Support us
    • Partnerships
    • Our prime minister patrons
    • Donate to our collection
    • eCommerce terms and conditions
    • Online house rules

    Blog

    Prime Ministers

    Websites

    Further information

    View our recruitment opportunities.

    View our copyright policy.

    View our privacy statement.

    View our ticketing terms and conditions.

    Questions about the website:
    website@moadoph.gov.au

    The Museum of Australian Democracy at Old Parliament House is a Corporate Commonwealth Entity within the Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development, Communications and the Arts